Common Misconceptions About Probate Law in Florida’s Probate System

Are you considering dividing your assets after death or inheriting a loved one’s estate? You might be curious about how your probate will unfold. Unfortunately, many people misunderstand probate, leading to confusion about what the law says. In this article, we will clear up the common Florida probate law myths so you can separate fact from fiction and take informed next steps.

What is Probate in Florida?

Probate in Florida is a legal process in which a court helps manage a person’s assets after they pass away. This includes identifying their property, paying debts, and giving the remaining assets to the rightful heirs. Chapters 731 to 735 of Florida’s Statutes outline the probate rules.

Florida recognizes two main types of probate. These include formal administration and summary administration. Most estates follow the usual process of summary administration. Summary administration simplifies the process for small estates with less than $75,000 in non-exempt assets or if the person passed away over two years ago.

---

Is Probate Always Required in Florida? Myths vs. Reality

A common misunderstanding about Florida probate is that all property needs to go through probate after death. When, in reality, the court only requires probate for assets the deceased person individually owned without a beneficiary designation or joint owner with survivorship rights. Moreover, certain exempt assets can bypass the probate in Florida.

Assets that Pass Outside of Probate in Florida

The Florida Law allows the surviving spouse to obtain the exempt assets before paying any creditor’s claims. The deceased’s children get a share of the estate if no surviving spouse exists. Exempt assets could be any personal property that sums up to $20,000. This could be a family vehicle, furniture, or appliances. Moreover, the statute exempts all qualified tuition programs authorized by section 529 of the Internal Revenue Code 1986.

Besides the exempt assets, the following estate types can bypass the probate:

• Co-owned property: the co-owners with survivorship rights automatically get the ownership of the assets.
• Designated beneficiaries include life insurance policies, retirement accounts, and payable-on-death or transfer-on-death accounts.
• Assets held in a living trust: Personal property or assets placed in a trust are dealt with according to the trust’s terms and can avoid probate.
• Property held as tenants by the entirety typically applies to married couples, where ownership passes to the surviving spouse.

---

Debunking the Common Florida Probate Law Myths

2020-2021 Probate Court Statistical Reference Guide shows that state-wide probate court filings increased nearly 50% over the last 10 years. This shows that probate is a common experience for Florida families. However, misconceptions remain widespread despite the growing prevalence of probate cases.

Let’s debunk the top myths about probate in Florida that can cause confusion and costly mistakes.

Probate Takes Years to Complete

Among the common Florida probate law myths is that probate is an extensive process that lasts years. However, in reality, the probate duration varies significantly for different types of probate, such as formal administration, summary administration, and disposition without administration.

Under normal circumstances, formal probate takes 6-9 months. This duration covers the appointment of a named personal representative, filing the will within 10 days, the creditor’s 90 days, paying the creditor’s claims, and more. Summary probate is much shorter, usually 2-3 weeks. For exceptional cases, such as a wrongful death lawsuit, the estate administration stays open for several years before resolving the lawsuit.

Probate is Always Expensive

Costs are another key factor in the misunderstandings about Florida probate. Despite popular belief, the costs depend on the estate’s value and complexity and are governed by law. Florida Statutes establish a sliding scale for attorney fees based on the estate’s value. As the estate value increases, the percentage rate for fees typically decreases. Moreover, if someone challenges the will or shows mistrust of the executor, additional costs would cover litigation of these claims.

Here are the primary expenses you should anticipate in Florida probate:

• Attorney Fees: These are typically calculated as a percentage of the estate’s value
• Court Filing Fees: Required for opening the probate case
• Executor Fees: Separate from attorney fees and based on estate complexity
• Publication Costs: Fees for legally required notices in local newspapers

Keep in mind that each estate is unique, and actual costs can vary significantly based on factors like estate complexity, family dynamics, and whether any disputes arise during the process. An experienced probate attorney can provide a more accurate estimate based on your specific situation.

The Probate Attorney Represents The Beneficiaries

This myth is another common probate misconception in Florida. A probate attorney does not represent the beneficiaries but the will’s executor. The executor, or personal representative, manages the estate and distributes it according to the will. While the probate attorney can provide basic information to the beneficiaries, they cannot lawfully give specific legal advice. If a beneficiary has a claim against the will, they must hire legal counsel to represent their interests.

The Probate Court Erases the Debts After Death

This concept highlights one of the top myths about probate in Florida. Florida statutes require the estate to settle unpaid bills and outstanding debts. To do this, you must publish a notice for potential creditors in the local newspaper. However, even when the creditors are entitled to their payments, they cannot receive the funds until the probate process is complete.

The deceased’s spouse and children do not have to pay the debt. The estate is used for the payment, and the probate court distributes the payments. The court will pay the bills from the estate’s funds. If the funds are insufficient, the court discusses payment plans with creditors. The court may also forgive some bills, such as those related to medical or probate fees.

The Executor Can Immediately Distribute Assets to Beneficiaries

Among the many Florida probate law myths is the belief that the executor will distribute the inherited assets immediately after a person’s death. The executor cannot divide the assets until the court grants them legal authority to act on the will.

Moreover, the executor must either be a Florida resident or a close family member of the deceased. Once they meet this requirement, the court issues letters of administration to officially appoint the executor. Even then, the executor must fulfill specific responsibilities before distributing the estate.

Executor Responsibilities in Florida Probate Before Distributing the Assets:

• Secure financial documents, keys, personal belongings, and real estate premises.
• Obtain the decedent’s death certificate and gather the last will.
• Collect titles, tax returns, life insurance policies, financial statements, etc.
• Filing the will with the probate court and notify beneficiaries, heirs, and creditors.
• Create a list of the assets and obtain appraisals to determine their value.
• Identify and pay creditor claims for any required income and estate tax returns.

---

Misconceptions About Florida Wills and Probate

A 2024 survey conducted by Caring.com shows that only 32% of Americans have a will, and 60% of those without a will had no living trust or proper estate planning document. The data highlights that many younger people believe estate planning is unnecessary and overlook the complexities of probate.

All Wills Must Go Through Probate

Several myths about avoiding the Florida probate include the idea that all wills must go through it. Although probate is the standard process for passing the deceased’s assets to the rightful heirs, proper estate planning tools, such as joint ownership, beneficiary designations, and living trusts, can help avoid probate.

Moreover, summary representation allows the surviving heir to collect or distribute assets without the lengthy duration of estate administration, which is beneficial for small estates.

Naming Beneficiaries Keeps Things Out of Probate

This concept highlights one of the many misunderstood rules about probate in Florida. In Florida, even if beneficiaries are designated, you must still file the will in probate court. The named personal representative will oversee the asset distribution. Moreover, accounts with transfer-on-death (TOD) designations, retirement accounts, or life insurance policies usually bypass probate.

Under certain circumstances, such as when the spouse is left out or receives less than 30%, they can challenge the distribution, regardless of the will or named beneficiary designations. Under Florida law, a surviving spouse can claim 30% of the deceased’s elective estate, including probate and non-probate assets.

No Will Means the State Gets Everything

The state can acquire property when a person dies; however, it is scarce. Usually, when someone dies without a will, the heirs or the next of kin receive the decedent’s property. This involves a complex hierarchical process that starts with the spouse and children and ends with reaching any living relative.

---

Homestead Property Probate Myths in Florida

Under Section 10, Article 4 of the Florida law, homestead property is the decedent’s primary residence, with limits of one-half acre inside city limits or up to 160 acres outside. The law requires that the deceased personally own the property, not companies or irrevocable trusts.

While the law provides clear guidelines about the homestead in probate, some misconceptions can cause confusion.

Homestead Property Always Avoids Probate

Homestead property may avoid probate under certain conditions, but not always. If the property is devised adequately in the will, it can pass directly to the heirs without probate. However, if the decedent leaves an improperly devised will or no will at all, transfer of ownership will require the probate. The court overlooks this process to determine the correct beneficiaries based on Florida’s intestate succession rules.

Probate Can Take Away the Homestead Property

Among the many myths about avoiding Florida probate is that you may lose your homestead due to probate. In most cases, homestead property is kept safe from potential creditors during the probate process and until the distribution of assets.

This means it goes to the deceased person’s heirs or spouse without the debt claims affecting it. However, any voluntary debts, such as a mortgage or a contractor’s bill, are charged against the homestead property.

Key Points to Know About Florida’s Probate for Homestead Property:

• Surviving Spouse: The surviving spouse can live in the homestead for the rest of their lives or claim a 50% ownership interest.
• Minor Children: If any minor children are living in the house, the court does not allow selling the property in a way that displaces them.
• How Inheritance Works: If there are no surviving spouses or minor children, the property passes to parents, siblings, extended family members, and finally, the last living relative.
• Special Cases: Under Florida’s intestacy laws, stepchildren are not considered heirs but can inherit property if designated in the will.

---

Florida Probate Law Myths FAQs

Does the personal representative have to pay the estate’s debts personally?

No, a personal representative does not have to pay the estate’s debts with their own money. They use the estate’s assets to pay debts. However, if they mismanage the funds or fail to follow legal rules, they can be held personally responsible for any losses or unpaid debts that result.

Key Takeaways About Common Probate Misconceptions in Florida

Clearing up common Florida probate law myths can make the process less stressful and help you avoid costly mistakes. Many think probate is always required, takes forever, or costs a fortune—but that’s not always true. In many cases, some assets can even skip probate entirely.

Learning about Florida’s specific probate rules can guide your next steps. This way, you can make better choices that honor your loved one’s wishes and protect your interests. Getting the correct information is the key to making the process easier for everyone involved.